- It is difficult to attribute
crashes to sleepiness because there is no test to determine
its presence as there is for intoxication (i.e., a “breathalyzer”).
In addition, there are no standardized criteria for determining
driver sleepiness and there is little or no police training
in identifying drowsiness crash factors. Also, to date, six
states (Alabama, Missouri, Arkansas, Delaware, Massachusetts,
and Wisconsin) do not have a code for sleepiness on their
crash report forms.
- The U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
(NHTSA) estimates that approximately 100,000 police-reported
crashes annually (about 1.5% of all crashes) involve drowsiness/
fatigue as a principal causal factor. A conservative estimate
of related fatalities is 1,500 annually or 4% of all traffic
crash fatalities. At least 71,000 people are injured in fall-asleep
crashes each year. NHTSA estimates these crashes represent
$12.5 billion in monetary losses each year.
- Drowsiness/fatigue may play a role in crashes attributed
to other causes. About one million crashes annually – one-sixth
of all crashes – are thought to be produced by driver
inattention/ lapses. Sleep deprivation and fatigue make such
lapses of attention more likely to occur.
- In a 1999 NSF poll, 62% of all adults surveyed reported
driving a car or other vehicle while feeling drowsy in the
prior year. Twenty-seven percent reported that they had,
at some time, dozed off while driving. Twenty-three percent
of adults stated that they know someone who experienced a
fall-asleep crash within the past year.
- People tend to fall asleep more on high-speed, long, boring,
rural highways. New York police estimate that 30% of all
fatal crashes along the New York Thruway occurred because
the driver fell asleep at the wheel.
WHO IS MOST AT R I S K ?
All Drivers who Are:
- Sleep-deprived or fatigued
- Driving long distances without rest breaks
- Driving through the night, the early afternoon, or at
other times when they are normally asleep
- Taking medication that increases sleepiness or drinking
alcohol
- Driving alone
- Driving on long, rural, boring roads
- Frequent travelers, e.g., business travelers
Young People
Sleep-related crashes are most common in
young people, who tend to stay up late, sleep too little,
and drive at night. In a North Carolina state study, 55%
of fall-asleep crashes involved people 25 years old or younger.
78% were males. The peak age of occurrence was 20.
Shift Workers
25 million Americans are rotating shift workers. Studies
suggest that 20 to 30% of those with non-traditional work
schedules have had a fatigue-related driving mishap within
the last year. The drive home from work after the night shift
is likely to be a particularly dangerous one.
Commercial Drivers
Truck drivers are especially
susceptible to fatigue-related crashes. In addition to the
high number of miles driven each year, many truckers may
drive during the night when the body is sleepiest. Truckers
may also have a high prevalence of a sleep and breathing
disorder called sleep apnea. Studies suggest truck driver
fatigue may be a contributing factor in at least 30 to 40
percent of all heavy truck accidents.
People with Undiagnosed Sleep Disorders
The presence of a sleep disorder increases the risk of crashes.
Disorders such as chronic insomnia, sleep apnea and narcolepsy,
all of which lead to excessive daytime sleepiness, afflict
an estimated 30 million Americans. Most people with sleep
disorders remain undiagnosed and untreated. Sleep apnea occurs
in 4% of middle-aged men and 2% of middle-aged women. The
disorder is associated with a three- to seven- time increase
in crash risk.
WHAT ARE EFFECTIVE COUNTERMEASURES?
Before motorists embark on their trips, they should:
- Get a good night’s sleep. While this varies from
individual to individual, the average person requires about
8 hours of sleep a night.
- Plan to drive long trips with a companion. Passengers
can help look for early warning signs of fatigue or switch
drivers when needed. Passengers should stay awake to talk
to the driver.
- Schedule regular stops, every 100 miles or 2 hours.
- Avoid alcohol and medications (over-the-counter and prescribed)
that may impair performance. Alcohol interacts with fatigue;
increasing its effects — just like drinking on an
empty stomach.
- Consult your physician or a local sleep disorders center
for diagnosis and treatment if you suffer frequent daytime
sleepiness, have difficulty sleeping at night often, and/or
snore loudly every night.
Once driving, motorists should look for the following
warning signs of fatigue:
- You can’t remember the last few miles driven
- You drift from your lane or hit a rumble strip
- You experience wandering or disconnected thoughts
- You yawn repeatedly
- You have difficulty focusing or keeping your eyes open
- You tailgate or miss traffic signs
- You have trouble keeping your head up
- You keep jerking your vehicle back into the lane
If you are tired, recognize that you are in danger
of falling asleep and cannot predict when a microsleep
may occur.
- Don’t count on the radio, open window or other “tricks” to
keep you awake.
- Respond to symptoms of fatigue by finding a safe place
to stop for a break.
- Pull off into a safe area away from traffic and take
a brief nap (15 to 45 minutes) if tired.
Drink coffee or another source of caffeine to promote short-term
alertness if needed. (It takes about 30 minutes for caffeine
to enter the bloodstream.) |